探索与争鸣 ›› 2025, Vol. 1 ›› Issue (8): 82-92.

• 学术争鸣 • 上一篇    下一篇

法典编纂与环境治理体系现代化|迈向被害人权益保护的环境刑法变革

蒋济泽   

  • 出版日期:2025-09-20 发布日期:2025-08-20
  • 作者简介:蒋济泽,同济大学法学院助理教授。(上海 200092)
  • 基金资助:
    教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目“刑罚现代化视域下智慧矫正质效提升机制研究”(24YJC840014)

Towards a Reform of Environmental Criminal Law for the Protection of Victims’ Rights and Interests

Jiang Jize
  

  • Online:2025-09-20 Published:2025-08-20

摘要: 环境刑法是环境治理的重要保障,但当前环境治理中却出现了刑法保障边缘化、被害人参与流于形式,环境犯罪制裁体系存在惩罚与恢复结构性失衡的问题。从法理上分析,导致当前困境的原因在于,环境法益的二元割裂使个人利益与生态权益保护失衡,环境刑法的功能与治理实践存在偏差制约环境刑法的实效,参与主体的角色与逻辑固化进一步阻碍被害人权益的实质化救济。在刑罚现代化的背景下,环境刑法应转向系统性法益救济理念,融合谦抑性与恢复性司法,通过创新替代性制裁方案、厘清刑行界限、强化公众参与及畅通被害人救济渠道等路径,实现环境刑法的功能革新与效能提升,推动实现被害人权益保护的实质化。

关键词: 环境刑法, 被害人权益, 法益救济, 恢复性司法, 刑罚现代化

Abstract:

Environmental criminal law serves as an important guarantee for environmental governance. However, in current environmental governance, there are issues such as the marginalization of criminal law safeguards, the formalistic nature of victim participation mechanisms, and a structural imbalance between punishment and restoration in the environmental crime sanction system. From a jurisprudential perspective, the reasons for the current predicament lie in the dual division of environmental legal interests, which causes an imbalance in the protection of personal and ecological rights and interests. There is also a deviation between the functions of environmental criminal law and governance practices, restricting the effectiveness of environmental criminal law. Additionally, the rigidification of the roles and logic of participating entities further hinders the substantive relief of victims’ rights and interests. Based on the perspective of penal modernization, environmental criminal law should shift towards the concept of systematic legal interest relief, integrate the principles of penal moderation and restorative justice. Through paths such as innovating alternative sanction schemes, clarifying the boundaries between criminal and administrative law, strengthening public participation, and facilitating smooth channels for victim relief, it can achieve functional innovation and efficiency enhancement of environmental criminal law, and promote the
substantive protection of victims’ rights and interests.

Key words: